Choosing the right credit card processing solution is critical for businesses operating both in-store and online in 2026. Merchant One and Square represent two fundamentally different approaches to payment processing, each with distinct advantages for hybrid business models.
This comprehensive 2026 comparison breaks down pricing, hardware options, online payment tools, contract terms, and real-world performance to help you choose the best platform for your specific business needs.
➡️ Read next (recommended)
📋 Table of Contents
- 1. 2026 Quick Verdict: Merchant One vs Square
- 2. Pricing Comparison (2026 Rates)
- 3. Hardware Options & Costs
- 4. Online Payment Tools Comparison
- 5. Contract Terms & Flexibility
- 6. Integration & Software Compatibility
- 7. Customer Support & Reliability
- 8. Best For Different Business Types
- 9. Decision Guide: How to Choose
2026 Quick Verdict: Merchant One vs Square
Before diving into detailed comparisons, here's our 2026 quick verdict based on extensive testing and real business feedback:
🏆 Winner for Large-Volume Businesses: Merchant One
Choose Merchant One if: You process over $10,000/month, need interchange-plus pricing, want dedicated account management, require extensive POS integrations, and prioritize cost optimization over simplicity.
🏆 Winner for SMBs & Startups: Square
Choose Square if: You're a small to medium business, value simplicity and transparency, need quick setup, want free basic hardware, process under $10,000/month, and prefer month-to-month flexibility.
Processing Volume vs Platform Fit
($0-5K/month) Growing Business
($5-20K/month) Large Business
($20K+/month)
Square excels at lower volumes; Merchant One becomes cost-effective at higher volumes
2026 Pricing Comparison
Understanding the true cost of payment processing requires looking beyond advertised rates to effective rates after all fees.
| Fee Type | Merchant One | Square | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| In-Person Processing | Interchange + 0.15% + $0.08 | 2.6% + $0.10 | Merchant One saves 0.3-0.5% at $10K+ volume |
| Online Payments | Interchange + 0.20% + $0.10 | 2.9% + $0.30 | Merchant One saves 0.4-0.6% at high volume |
| Keyed/Card Not Present | Interchange + 0.25% + $0.15 | 3.5% + $0.15 | Merchant One saves 0.8-1.2% |
| Monthly Fees | $15-25/month | $0/month (basic) | Square wins for low-volume businesses |
| Terminal Rental | $20-50/month | Free basic reader | Square offers better entry hardware |
| PCI Compliance | $10-15/month | Free with account | Square includes compliance |
💰 2026 Processing Cost Calculator
Hardware Options & Costs (2026)
Both platforms offer different hardware ecosystems tailored to their business models.
Merchant One Hardware Options
TraditionalCountertop Terminals
Dejavoo Z11, Verifone VX520
$20-50/month lease
Mobile Readers
PAX A920, Dejavoo QD2
$30-60/month lease
POS Systems
Clover, Micros, Revel
$50-150/month lease
Virtual Terminal
Browser-based
$0 (included)
📊 Hardware Cost Analysis
Restaurant Case Study: A medium-sized restaurant using Merchant One with Clover POS pays $89/month for hardware ($69 Clover + $20 terminal). Over 3 years: $3,204. Square's comparable package: $60/month for Square for Restaurants + $49/month for Clover hardware alternative = $109/month ($3,924 over 3 years). Merchant One saves $720 over 3 years for high-volume restaurants.
Square Hardware Options
ModernFree Basic Reader
Square Reader for Magstripe
$0 (first one free)
Contactless + Chip Reader
Square Reader for Contactless and Chip
$49 one-time
Square Terminal
All-in-one countertop device
$299 one-time
Square Register
Complete POS system
$799-1,099 one-time
📊 Startup Advantage
Retail Startup: A new boutique can start processing cards immediately with Square's free magstripe reader. Total hardware investment: $0. With Merchant One, minimum hardware cost would be $20/month ($240/year). For businesses with uncertain early growth, Square's pay-as-you-go hardware model significantly reduces startup risk and capital requirements.
Online Payment Tools Comparison
Both platforms offer comprehensive online payment solutions, but with different approaches to e-commerce integration.
| Feature | Merchant One | Square | Best Implementation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Payment Gateway | Authorize.net, NMI | Square Payments | Square has tighter integration |
| E-commerce Plugins | WooCommerce, Shopify, Magento | Square for WooCommerce, etc. | Square's plugins are more polished |
| Recurring Billing | Add-on ($20-40/month) | Built-in (no extra cost) | Square includes basic recurring |
| Virtual Terminal | Built-in (no extra cost) | Square Dashboard | Both excellent for MOTO |
| API Documentation | Standard REST API | Excellent REST API | Square's API is more modern |
| Mobile SDK | Basic | Excellent (iOS/Android) | Square wins for mobile apps |
Integration & Software Compatibility
How well each platform integrates with existing business software stacks.
Merchant One Integration
Enterprise Focus🏢 Best For Established Businesses
Merchant One excels with businesses already using traditional POS systems like Micros, Aloha, or Revel. Their extensive integration list means you likely won't need to change your existing hardware/software stack.
Square Integration
Modern Ecosystem🚀 Best For Modern Businesses
Square's strength is its unified ecosystem. If you use Square POS, Square Online Store, Square Appointments, and Square Loyalty, everything works seamlessly together with single-login convenience.
Contract Terms & Flexibility (2026)
The contractual differences between these platforms significantly impact business flexibility.
Typically 3-year contracts with early termination fees ($295-495). Some month-to-month options available for established businesses at higher rates.
No long-term contracts. Month-to-month flexibility. Cancel anytime without fees. Perfect for seasonal businesses or those testing the platform.
Merchant One: Rates often negotiable, especially for $20K+ monthly volume. Square: Generally non-negotiable flat rates with occasional volume discounts for $250K+ annually.
Merchant One: May require rolling reserves for new/high-risk businesses. Square: Sometimes holds funds for new accounts but less common than traditional processors.
Customer Support & Reliability (2026)
Support quality can significantly impact your day-to-day operations.
| Support Feature | Merchant One | Square | Our Experience |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phone Support | 24/7 dedicated lines | Limited hours, often wait times | Merchant One more accessible |
| Dedicated Rep | Yes (for most accounts) | No (general support only) | Merchant One provides personal touch |
| Email Support | 24-48 hour response | 2-24 hour response | Square slightly faster |
| Online Resources | Basic documentation | Excellent knowledge base | Square's resources are superior |
| Uptime/Reliability | 99.9%+ SLA | 99.95%+ generally | Both extremely reliable |
Best For Different Business Types (2026)
Your business type and volume significantly influence which platform makes more sense.
Restaurants & Food Service
Industry Focus🍽️ Restaurant Case Study
Full-Service Restaurant: Using Aloha POS with Merchant One processing $40K/month pays ~1.8% effective rate ($720/month). Square equivalent would be ~2.6% ($1,040/month). Merchant One saves $320/month ($3,840/year). The 3-year contract makes sense given restaurant stability.
Retail Stores
Industry Focus🛍️ Retail Case Study
Boutique Clothing Store: Processing $8K/month. Square costs ~2.6% ($208/month) with free hardware. Merchant One would be ~2.1% ($168/month) but with $35/month hardware lease = $203/month. Square wins by $5/month with better software features and no contract.
Decision Guide: How to Choose in 2026
Follow this systematic approach to make the right choice for your specific situation.
Step 1: Calculate Your True Costs
- Estimate Monthly Volume: Use your last 3 months of statements
- Calculate Average Ticket: Total sales ÷ number of transactions
- Consider Growth: Project 6-12 month growth
- Use Our Calculator: Input your numbers above
Step 2: Evaluate Your Business Needs
✅ Choose Merchant One If:
- Processing over $10,000/month consistently
- Already using traditional POS hardware
- Need dedicated account management
- Want interchange-plus pricing transparency
- Business is stable (won't close in 3 years)
✅ Choose Square If:
- Processing under $10,000/month
- Starting new business or seasonal
- Value simplicity and quick setup
- Want free basic hardware
- Need month-to-month flexibility
- Prefer modern, integrated software
Step 3: Consider These 2026 Trends
More businesses need both in-store and online processing. Square's unified system handles this seamlessly, while Merchant One requires separate gateway setup.
Contactless payments now 65% of in-person transactions. Square's hardware is optimized for this trend with better tap-to-pay experiences.
Both platforms are PCI compliant, but Square includes more security features (tokenization, encryption) at no extra cost.
🎯 Our 2026 Recommendation
For most small to medium businesses: Start with Square. The month-to-month flexibility, free hardware options, and integrated software suite provide the best value under $10,000/month in processing volume. If/when you grow beyond $10,000/month consistently, re-evaluate and potentially switch to Merchant One for better rates.
For established businesses over $20,000/month: Merchant One likely offers better long-term value, especially if you already have POS hardware and don't need Square's software features.
🚀 Next Steps to Take
- Get Square's free reader to test with your business
- Request a quote from Merchant One if over $10K/month
- Run parallel processing for 30 days if switching
- Review contracts carefully before signing anything
- Monitor processing costs monthly to ensure you're getting promised rates
✅ Keep Learning
Frequently Asked Questions
Generally no. Square maintains uniform pricing for transparency. However, businesses processing over $250,000 annually may qualify for custom pricing through Square's enterprise division. For most SMBs, you'll pay the published rates: 2.6% + $0.10 for in-person, 2.9% + $0.30 for online.
Watch for: 1) PCI compliance fees ($10-15/month), 2) Monthly minimums ($25/month if processing under threshold), 3) Statement fees ($5-10/month), 4) Batch fees ($0.10-0.25 per batch), 5) Early termination fees ($295-495). Always request a complete fee schedule before signing.
Merchant One generally has more flexible underwriting for higher-risk categories. Square tends to be more restrictive and may hold funds or close accounts without warning for businesses they deem high-risk. Always disclose your business type accurately to both platforms during application.
No. Square hardware is proprietary and only works with Square's processing. Similarly, Merchant One's processing requires compatible hardware from their approved list. You cannot mix-and-match hardware between these ecosystems.
Square: Typically same-day approval. You can order hardware and start processing with the free reader immediately. Merchant One: 2-5 business days for underwriting approval, plus shipping time for hardware (5-10 business days). Setup assistance may be needed for terminal configuration.
Square: Cancel anytime from your dashboard. No fees. Funds continue processing normally. Merchant One: Early termination fees apply (typically $295-495). You must return leased hardware. Allow 30-45 days for final settlement and account closure.