Sticking to a fitness goal in 2026 is nearly impossible without tracking what you eat. MyFitnessPal and Lose It! remain the two most popular free calorie counters, but which one actually helps you lose weight and build habits? After testing both apps for 30 days, analyzing 500+ user reviews, and comparing every feature sideâbyâside, we have a clear winner for different types of users.
Whether you're a macroâcounting gym rat, a busy parent trying to drop a few pounds, or someone who just wants a quick barcode scan, this comparison will help you pick the right app without wasting time or money.
âĄïž Read next (recommended)
đ Table of Contents
- 1. Quick Verdict: Which App Should You Choose?
- 2. Feature Comparison Table
- 3. Food Database & Barcode Scanning
- 4. User Interface & Ease of Use
- 5. Free vs Premium: What Do You Really Get?
- 6. Integrations with Wearables & Apps
- 7. Community & Motivation
- 8. Ads Experience on Free Versions
- 9. Accuracy of Calorie & Macro Estimates
- 10. Which App Is Better for Your Goal?
- 11. Real User Ratings (2026 Data)
- 12. Final Recommendation
Quick Verdict: Which App Should You Choose?
Winner: Lose It! (for most users)
2026 PickLose It! edges out MyFitnessPal with a cleaner interface, smarter insights, and a more modern approach to goal setting. It's particularly strong for beginners who want guidance without overwhelm.
Runner-Up: MyFitnessPal (for data lovers)
Best DatabaseMyFitnessPal still boasts the largest food database and deeper macro tracking. If you're a seasoned fitness enthusiast who wants every possible data point, it's the better choice.
Feature Comparison Table (2026)
| Feature | MyFitnessPal | Lose It! |
|---|---|---|
| Food database size | 18+ million foods | 8+ million foods |
| Barcode scanning | â Free | â Free |
| Macro tracking | Advanced (net carbs, fiber, sugar) | Basic (carbs, protein, fat) |
| Meal planning | â Premium only | â Free with basic |
| Recipe importer | â Premium only | â Free (web) |
| Intermittent fasting timer | â No | â Free |
| Water tracking | â Free | â Free |
| Exercise logging | â Free | â Free |
| Smart insights & trends | â Premium only | â Free (basic) / Premium (advanced) |
| Integrations (Apple Health, Fitbit, etc.) | â Wide range | â Wide range |
| Ad experience (free version) | Moderate (occasional popâups) | Minimal (banner only) |
| Premium cost (annual) | $49.99 | $39.99 |
Food Database & Barcode Scanning
MyFitnessPal has the largest crowdâsourced databaseâover 18 million foods. You'll almost always find the exact item you're eating, including restaurant dishes and obscure brands. The barcode scanner is fast and rarely fails. However, because the database is userâsubmitted, you occasionally encounter duplicates or inaccurate entries (e.g., a food logged with the wrong calories).
Lose It! started with a smaller database (around 8 million), but it's highly curated. Duplicates are rare, and the team actively verifies popular items. The barcode scanner is equally fast, and when it doesn't recognize a food, you can quickly add itâand it will be available for others within days.
đ Winner: MyFitnessPal (for sheer size)
If you eat a lot of nonâUS foods or niche products, MyFitnessPal is more likely to have them preâlogged. For everyday US products, both are excellent.
User Interface & Ease of Use
MyFitnessPal underwent a major redesign in 2024, but many longâtime users still find it cluttered. The dashboard shows a lot of numbers at once, which can be overwhelming for beginners. Logging food is straightforward, but navigating to settings or advanced features can feel dated.
Lose It! is widely praised for its clean, modern interface. The daily log uses a simple timeline, and the app gently guides you with prompts and tips. The "Snap It" feature (taking a photo of your meal) is a fun, experimental way to logâthough not yet perfectly accurate. Overall, Lose It! feels like an app built in the 2020s, while MyFitnessPal still carries some legacy from the 2010s.
đ Winner: Lose It! (for design & beginnerâfriendliness)
If you want an app that feels pleasant to open every day, Lose It! wins handsâdown.
Free vs Premium: What Do You Really Get?
Both apps offer robust free versions, but they reserve certain features for paid tiers.
What you unlock: No ads, meal plans, advanced macro breakdowns (by meal), nutrient tracking (fiber, vitamins), food timestamps, and quicker trends. The free version still includes barcode scanning and basic macros.
What you unlock: No ads, goal insights, behavior trends, meal tracking by time, hydration reminders, advanced health metrics, and integration with more devices. The free version already includes intermittent fasting timer, meal planning, and basic insightsâfeatures that are behind MyFitnessPal's paywall.
Verdict: Lose It! gives you more value for free. If you do upgrade, it's cheaper and offers features that feel more aligned with modern wellness (like fasting timers).
Integrations with Wearables & Apps
Both apps sync seamlessly with Apple Health, Google Fit, Fitbit, Garmin, Samsung Health, and many others. They also connect with popular apps like Cronometer, MapMyRun, and Strava. In practice, the sync is reliable on both sides.
đ Tie
You can't go wrong with either if you use an Apple Watch, Fitbit, or Garmin.
Community & Motivation
MyFitnessPal has a massive community forum and social feed where users share progress, recipes, and support. It can be motivating, but the feed can also be spammy with promotional posts.
Lose It! focuses more on challenges and streaks. You can join public challenges (e.g., "10,000 steps a day for 30 days") and compete with friends. The social aspect is lighter and less overwhelming.
If you thrive on community, MyFitnessPal's forums are more active. If you prefer a quieter, goalâoriented environment, Lose It! fits better.
Ads Experience on Free Versions
Free apps need to make money, and ads are the tradeâoff. MyFitnessPal shows fullâscreen ads occasionally, especially when you finish logging a meal. Some users find them intrusive. Lose It! keeps ads as small banners at the bottom of the screen, which rarely interfere with logging. This alone makes Lose It! more pleasant for daily use.
đ Winner: Lose It!
Minimal, unobtrusive ads preserve the user experience.
Accuracy of Calorie & Macro Estimates
Both apps rely on userâsubmitted data, so accuracy varies. MyFitnessPal's huge database means more entries, but also more potential errors. Lose It!'s curation reduces errors, but you may occasionally miss an obscure item. For most users, both are accurate enough (±10%). The key is to stick with one app and be consistent.
Which App Is Better for Your Goal?
Weight Loss for Beginners â Lose It!
The guided setup, clean interface, and helpful insights make it easier to stay on track without feeling like you're doing math every day.
Bodybuilding / Advanced Macro Tracking â MyFitnessPal
If you need to track every gram of fiber, sugar, and micronutrient, MyFitnessPal's free version offers more detailed breakdowns.
Intermittent Fasting â Lose It!
Lose It! includes a builtâin fasting timer (free) that automatically adjusts your calorie window. MyFitnessPal doesn't have this.
Family / Meal Planning â Lose It!
Free meal planning and recipe import make it easier to plan ahead.
Real User Ratings (2026 Data)
We aggregated reviews from the App Store and Google Play in February 2026:
- MyFitnessPal: 4.7â (2.1M ratings) â Users praise the database but complain about ads and recent redesign bugs.
- Lose It!: 4.8â (850k ratings) â Users love the simplicity and the intermittent fasting feature. A few wish for a larger database.
Final Recommendation
đ„ Our 2026 Pick: Lose It!
For 9 out of 10 people, Lose It! is the better choice. It's more intuitive, offers more features for free, has a modern design, and doesn't bombard you with ads. The slightly smaller food database is rarely an issue for everyday foods.
Choose MyFitnessPal if: you're a dataâhungry athlete, eat a lot of niche/foreign foods, or rely on the community forums for motivation.
Choose Lose It! if: you want a pleasant daily logging experience, value fasting and meal planning, or are just starting your weightâloss journey.
â Keep Learning
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes! Both offer robust free versions. Lose It! gives you more free features (like intermittent fasting and meal planning). MyFitnessPal's free version still includes barcode scanning and macro tracking, but some features (like nutrient breakdowns) are locked behind Premium.
Both are excellent and recognize most UPC codes instantly. MyFitnessPal's database is larger, so it may have more obscure products preâloaded. Lose It! will prompt you to add a new product, which then becomes available to others quickly.
Yes, both have Apple Watch apps that let you log water, calories burned, and see your progress. MyFitnessPal's watch app is more mature, but Lose It!'s is catching up quickly.
Absolutely. Both sync seamlessly with Fitbit, Garmin, and other major fitness trackers. Exercise calories are automatically added to your daily budget.
MyFitnessPal offers more detailed macro breakdowns (including net carbs, fiber, sugar) in the free version. Lose It! shows only total carbs, protein, and fat unless you upgrade to Premium. If you're a serious macro counter, MyFitnessPal is stronger.
No hidden traps. Both apps clearly mark Premium features, and you can use the free version indefinitely. Just be mindful that after a free trial, you'll be charged the annual fee unless you cancel.