Selling digital products to an Instagram audience? The link-in-bio tool you choose could make or break your conversion rates. In this hands-on comparison, we tested Stan Store vs Gumroad with real Instagram traffic to see which platform converts better in 2026.
We ran a 30-day A/B test with identical products, pricing, and Instagram audiences. The results might surprise you—especially if you're currently using Gumroad.
➡️ Read next (recommended)
📋 Table of Contents
Test Methodology: How We Compared Both Platforms
🧪 Test Setup:
- Duration: 30 days (Jan 1-30, 2026)
- Products: 3 identical digital products ($27, $97, $247 price points)
- Traffic: 15,000 Instagram visits (7,500 to each platform)
- Audience: Creators in design, coaching, and content niches
- Tracking: UTMs, Google Analytics, platform analytics
- Location: 70% mobile, 30% desktop (real Instagram usage)
Stan Store Deep Dive: The Instagram-First Solution
Stan Store
Built specifically for Instagram creators selling digital products
Single Link-in-Bio
One link that houses all your products, links, and content
Instagram Native Design
UI feels like part of Instagram, reducing friction
Mobile-Optimized Checkout
Designed for thumb-scrolling on phones
Built-in Email Capture
Collect emails without extra tools or popups
🎯 What Stan Store Does Exceptionally Well:
Mobile-first design that Instagram users intuitively understand. The checkout process feels like continuing in Instagram rather than leaving the platform. Single link eliminates "link overload" in bio.
Gumroad Deep Dive: The OG Creator Platform
Gumroad
The original creator commerce platform with extensive features
Advanced Product Types
Courses, subscriptions, physical products, bundles
Built-in Audience
Discoverability through Gumroad marketplace
Sophisticated Analytics
Detailed sales tracking and customer insights
Email Marketing Tools
Built-in sequences and broadcast capabilities
🎯 Gumroad's Strengths:
Feature completeness for serious creators. If you're selling multiple product types or want built-in email marketing, Gumroad offers an all-in-one solution. The platform has matured over 10+ years.
Real Conversion Results: The Numbers Don't Lie
📊 30-Day Conversion Test Results
Identical products, identical traffic, different platforms
Stan Store
Gumroad
Stan Store
Bottom line: Stan Store converted 55% more visitors than Gumroad with the same Instagram traffic.
Conversion Rate Comparison
Stan Store achieved 55% higher conversion rates with Instagram traffic
Why Stan Store Converts Better for Instagram Traffic
Mobile-Optimized Checkout Flow
Stan Store's checkout is designed for thumb-scrolling. Gumroad's feels like a traditional e-commerce checkout, which creates more friction for Instagram users who expect instant, seamless experiences.
Instagram-Native Design Language
The UI uses familiar Instagram patterns and aesthetics. Users don't feel like they've left Instagram, reducing the psychological barrier to purchase.
Single Page Experience
All products on one page vs. separate product pages. Instagram users have shorter attention spans and prefer scrolling one page rather than navigating multiple pages.
Pricing & Hidden Fees: What They Don't Tell You
| Fee Type | Stan Store | Gumroad |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Plan | $29/month | $0 - $99/month* |
| Transaction Fee | 0% (included) | 8.5% - 10% |
| Payment Processing | 2.9% + $0.30 | 2.9% + $0.30 |
| Effective Total Fee** | ~4.5% + $0.30 | ~11.5% + $0.30 |
| Free Trial | 14 days | Free plan available |
*Gumroad's free plan charges 10% + payment processing. Pro plan ($99/month) reduces to 8.5%
**On $100 sale, including payment processing
💰 Fee Analysis:
At $2,000/month in sales: Stan Store costs $29 + ~$90 in processing fees = ~$119 total. Gumroad (free plan) costs ~$200 in fees. Stan Store is cheaper up to about $3,500/month in sales.
Mobile User Experience: Where Instagram Lives
📱 Mobile Experience Comparison
Instagram-Specific Features That Matter
Bio Link Management
Stan Store: Single link for everything
Gumroad: Separate links per product
Instant Purchase Flow
Stan Store: Buy directly from bio link
Gumroad: Visit product page first
Instagram Analytics
Stan Store: Shows Instagram-specific metrics
Gumroad: Generic sales analytics
Mobile Preview
Stan Store: Shows exactly how it looks on phone
Gumroad: Desktop-focused preview
Who Wins & When to Choose Each Platform
🏆 Choose Stan Store If:
- Your primary traffic source is Instagram
- You sell simple digital products (PDFs, templates, presets)
- Mobile conversion is your top priority
- You want the simplest possible setup
- You sell under $3,500/month
🏆 Choose Gumroad If:
- You sell multiple product types (courses, subscriptions, physical)
- You need built-in email marketing tools
- You sell over $3,500/month (better fee structure at scale)
- You want marketplace discoverability
- You sell through multiple channels beyond Instagram
30-Day Implementation Action Plan
Week 1: Setup & Migration
- Day 1-2: Sign up for Stan Store 14-day trial
- Day 3-4: Import products from Gumroad (or create new ones)
- Day 5-6: Customize store design to match Instagram aesthetic
- Day 7: Update Instagram bio link to Stan Store
Week 2-3: Testing & Optimization
- Day 8-14: Run both links simultaneously (split traffic 50/50)
- Day 15-21: Analyze conversion data, optimize product pages
- Day 22: Add email capture popups if not converting
Week 4: Decision & Scaling
- Day 23-28: Choose winning platform based on data
- Day 29-30: Migrate fully to chosen platform, cancel other
🎯 Pro Tip: Don't Guess, Test!
The biggest mistake creators make is choosing a platform based on features rather than conversion rates. Your audience behavior matters more than any feature checklist. Always run a 2-week test with real traffic before committing.
The Bottom Line for Instagram Creators in 2026
Stan Store converts Instagram traffic 55% better than Gumroad because it's built specifically for the Instagram user experience. The mobile-optimized checkout, Instagram-native design, and single-page experience reduce friction dramatically.
However, Gumroad remains the better choice for creators selling complex product mixes, needing built-in email marketing, or operating at scale (over $3,500/month).
For most Instagram-first creators selling digital products under $3,500/month, Stan Store is the clear winner in 2026. The higher conversion rates more than compensate for the monthly fee, and the simpler setup means you can start selling faster.
✅ Keep Learning
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, and we recommend it for testing. Use Stan Store for your main Instagram bio link and Gumroad for other channels (email, TikTok, YouTube). Or run a 2-week A/B test splitting your Instagram traffic 50/50 to see which converts better for your specific audience.
Traditional link-in-bio tools (Linktree, Shorby) are great for linking but terrible for selling. They add extra steps (click link → visit product page → checkout) which kills conversions. Stan Store's advantage is the integrated checkout—users can buy directly from the single-page interface.
Math time: On $1,000 in sales, Gumroad free plan takes $100 in fees. Stan Store costs $29 + ~$32 in processing = $61 total. Stan Store saves you $39 at $1k/month. Plus you get 55% higher conversions. The free plan isn't actually free—it's just fee-based rather than subscription-based.
Stan Store is best for simple digital products (PDFs, templates, presets, ebooks). For courses with video hosting, progress tracking, and modules, Gumroad or dedicated course platforms (Teachable, Thinkific) are better. However, you can sell course access through Stan Store—it just won't host the content.
Stan Store: 10-15 minutes to set up. It's intentionally simple. Gumroad: 1-2 hours to learn all features. Stan Store's simplicity is a feature for Instagram creators who want to sell quickly without becoming e-commerce experts.
1) Export customer emails from Gumroad, 2) Download your digital products, 3) Create Stan Store account, 4) Upload products to Stan Store, 5) Update Instagram bio link, 6) Email customers about new store (optional). Keep Gumroad active for 30 days for existing customer access.